An Ambiguous Disposition: Right of Survivorship on Bank Accounts

Late in 2019, the California Court of Appeal issued a decision (Placencia v Strazicich) which impacts people with beneficiaries on bank accounts. 

In the case, Ralph Placencia had a joint bank account that had an express right of survivorship in favor of one of his daughters. However, before he died, Ralph left a will stating that he wanted the proceeds of the bank account to go to all three of his daughters (not just the one whose name was jointly on his account). 

The conflict between the beneficiary designation and Ralph’s will lead to litigation. After analyzing the law, the court determined that a will, in and of itself, cannot render a beneficiary designation ineffective. However, the court did allow for a very limited circumstance where a decedent’s intent, shown by “clear and convincing” evidence, may invalidate a beneficiary designation. Even if that evidence is contained in statements made in a will. 

In other words: if you have a joint account with another person (e.g. a parent), the right of survivorship on the joint account is not absolute. Even though this court decision is very limited in scope, it does reinforce the principle that the right of survivorship will be determined by the decedent’s intent—which can be supported by statements made in a will, among other forms of evidence. 

Make your intentions clear. Almost every case dealing with an ambiguous gift will come down to the decedent’s intent.